An Adirondack Thanksgiving

Courtesy Animalia-life.club

The pictured Irish blessing is simply one that has always struck a chord with me. No more beautiful words have ever been strung together.

This is more of a story on the Thanksgivings of my boyhood, an amalgam of the various pieces and parts of a number of Thanksgivings blended into one. It would be impossible for me to choose a singular Thanksgiving from this period of my life, but, in looking back over my many years, these stand alone amidst my most cherished Thanksgiving memories.

When I was a boy, my brother, sister, parents and I would often gather to celebrate the Thanksgiving holiday with my grandparents in the heart of the Adirondack Mountains of northern New York. As kids, we were fortunate enough to have both our paternal grandparents and our maternal grandmother and extended families living within twenty miles of one another in some of the most beautiful country in all of the northeast.

By this time of year, the popular tourist region had slowed after the leaves of autumn had fallen. It would by then be cold and the days short, particularly that far north. We would have seen the first of the many winter snows and, back in the 70’s, the snow ran deep upon the land throughout the winter months.

My immediate family lived roughly ninety minutes to the south in the Saratoga area, north of the state’s capitol of Albany. Either the night before or early Thanksgiving morning, the five of us would excitedly pile in for the drive. It was not unusual for my dad to drive us there through a winter storm or at least some snow squalls on route. We’d be taking the “Northway”, a section of I-87 running north from Albany to the Canadian border. I always loved that it was formally named that by the state. If we were driving at night, I distinctly recall the mesmerizing effect of the snow coming towards us, arcing over the hood of the car. I would stare out the window and have skiers dreams as I would be skiing at my favorite mountain, Whiteface, at least one if not two days over the holiday weekend. As I came of age, I’d have to choose between whitetail deer hunting with my dad (another of my favorite things and it remain that way until after college when I moved west, to Colorado).

My younger sister and brother would typically fall into a deep slumber at some point during the drive and the car would mostly be silent with me awake in the backseat staring at the snow blowing by and both parents quiet, spinning down from the work-a-day world, he as an engineering supervisor for the state and she as an assistant manager for a bank. It wasn’t lost on me that the adult world wasn’t full of fun and games.

We’d get off the Northway and travel west, then north on Highway 9N passing several Adirondack landmarks such as Chapel Pond, the trailhead to Giant Mountain, and through well-known small Adirondack towns such as Keene Valley, where my mother grew up and the gateway to the High Peaks region, a large geologic cluster of forty-six mountains over 4,000 feet above sea level (ASL), and Keene, the gateway to Mt. Van Hovenburg (the one and only Olympic bobsled course in the US for half a century) and Lake Placid, a two-time site of the Winter Olympics.

When we hit the tiny town of Upper Jay, we’d cross the bridge over the East Branch of the Au Sable river, travel the last mile and a half, turn left up the steep concrete driveway which was built by my grandfather, and we were there! This was my dad’s home until he went off to college. We were all “home for the holidays”! To us kids, this was every bit as much home as was our house in a subdivision that ninety miles south. My dad still kept his room there with clothes and hunting and fishing gear. I would eventually populate his room with my own clothes and gear and we would share that room, with the now two twin beds, during our numerous trips “Up North” to hunt and fish.

The excitement was almost palpable as we walked in, and, after bliss-filled greetings with our grandparents in the kitchen, head straight for the great room to feel the kind of fire only my grandfather could build in his handcrafted granite and marble fireplace with the look of having held a thousand fires burning into the night. This was no ordinary fireplace, but a masterpiece built with my grandfather’s master craftsman’s hands, Huge, rectangular shaped hunks of granite with giant slabs of marble for the hearth and mantle. I believe he lifted each stone into place alone. Some of these pieces must have weighed a hundred pounds, or more Applying mortar and setting and leveling them solo would have been no mean feat.

At the west end of the room there was a long day bed and above it, a large picture window that we, as kids, could stare out of and view wildlife on the white pine filled hillside maybe seventy feet away.

We’d see all sorts of songbirds and partridges, squirrels, an occasional deer, porcupine, skunk, and once we caught a rare glimpse of a pine marten. The area was wild and many woodland creatures stayed out of sight. They had not yet become habituated to humans as many creatures living near human settlements have today. There were numerous large white pines surrounding the house providing shade in the summer and some protection from winter winds. Winter night-time temperatures regularly dipped to ten or fifteen below zero. Thanksgiving temperatures were more hospitable but it could still get quite cold, cold enough for snow to remain on the ground until the following spring.

If we’d driven up the night before, we’d, the seven of us, would gather in the great room and enjoy each other’s company for a short time before going off to bed. As I remember it, the house used heating oil stored in a hulking black tank in the cellar which fed a boiler and the boiler fed the heat registers in the upstairs sleeping quarters. Many of my older relatives had lived through the Great Depression, so they were frugal enough that most people today would find the lifestyle extremely uncomfortable. Register delivered heat was expensive, so, the fireplace was the home’s main source of heat. I don’t recall how many cords of firewood would be put up each fall, but I believe the wood shed must have held four or five cords. It is from them that I learned (and came to enjoy) keeping a cold house. The cellar doubled as cold storage for my grandmother’s canning operation with all sorts of fruit jams, pickled cucumbers, beans, tomatoes and other canned goods from the large garden. Two large freezers held an ample supply of frozen foods and quantities of both beef and venison. Other staples, including vegetables from the garden and sacks filled with potatoes, were stored in the root cellar which my grandfather had dug into the hillside when he built the garage and workshop. Again, being of the Depression Era, many of my relatives lived a quasi-subsistence lifestyle heavily reliant on their gardens and venison from deer harvested during hunting season each year. I looked up to them in a neverending awe and years later I would come to emulate their lifestyle, or, as close as I could come to it.

When I was old enough, I remember getting up early while the others were still asleep and building the morning fire. Learning how to build a good fire was just one of a thousand lessons I would carry with me for the rest of my life. Roughly an hour later, my grandmother would be serving up Thanksgiving breakfast replete with popovers (a tradition carried forward by my mom and then each of her offspring) pancakes, eggs, bacon, and hand-squeezed orange juice. I’d go out on the porch to read how cold it had gotten that night. Back then, before global warming had taken its firm grip on the environment, there was almost always enough snow to cover the ground completely, and, by Thanksgiving, temperatures were likely to dip from ten degrees above to just below zero (-F). By February, snowbanks lining the local roads would grow to five feet, or more.

The morning had us doing something outside. My four-years younger brother, Adam, and I might be out on the front porch practicing with our matching model 9422 Winchester rifles as given to us one fine Christmas when I might have been all of ten and he, just six. It was during times like this that gave my three-years-younger sister, Kristi, her own special time with our grandparents. This was important, and, though I didn’t piece it together as a kid, the Stone Adirondack household was very much a man’s world. My father had been an only child amongst not only his own parents, but my grandmother’s brother (my great uncle Bub) and aunt Rosemary and sister (my great aunt Rose) and uncle Francis. After retiring as a construction superintendent on industrial-scale projects all over the country and then closer to home in the Albany area, my grandfather seemed to be very much his own man and clearly enjoyed working alone. He could almost always be found outside working on the house he had refurbished, in his garage/workshop, or out on the property. Then my brother and I came along to share in all that masculine glory while my sister was left to carve her own way, which, incredibly, she somehow managed to do. Time spent with our grandmothers (on both sides) and other, older female Adirondack relatives had its own deep rewards. Adirondack women were strong willed, with powerful minds and were not to be trifled with. Our now eighty-five year-old mother is a torchbearer for that lineage.

We might then travel a mile up the road to go skating in a slough that my great uncle Bub would plow and trim back the willows so that we kids had our own private skating rink, at the edge of his section of woods and large hay meadow, virtually in the middle of nowhere except to be accompanied by nature, herself. When we were a bit older we would spend bitterly cold nights skating and playing hockey while some of the adults would join us, hanging-out near the warmth of a large bonfire. We would visit with my great uncle Bub and great aunt Rosemary, absolutely perfect human beings who never had the good fortune of having children of their own. The rest of the morning might be spent at my great aunt Rose and great uncle Francis’s loving home a mile and a half to the south, along the Au Sable river. At each stop, we’d be fed something from the family’s Thanksgiving recipe book.

By the time we returned to our grandparents’ house, we were already overfed for the day and Thanksgiving dinner was to be served in just an hour, maybe two. This is where things get a bit fuzzy for me. My dad had probably gotten up hours before dawn to go hunting. He preferred to hunt alone and his favored place for at least forty years was high up on Cascade mountain, a steep and rocky mountain just a thirty minute drive from his boyhood home where all of us were waiting for him to walk in through the door and tell us all that he’d gotten a Thanksgiving day buck! He would arrive just in time for our giant turkey dinner. After I turned fourteen, which was still several years away, I would be joining him. My mom would have been feeling a strong gravitational pill to be surrounded by not only us, but her own large family in Keene Valley. It is my best recollection that, as kids, we would be spending part of Thanksgiving or at least Thanksgiving weekend with her and her amazing family full of Adirondack men (uncles, grown cousins) that I also revered. My aunts were fine Adirondack women, as was my mom.

But, as memory serves, there were many years that my mother shared her Thanksgiving with us at my grandmother and grandfather Stone’s home before heading to her childhood home in Keene Valley on Thanksgiving night. Again, I am uncertain as to this part and how it all fit in. Some years, with the exception of my dad, the rest of us would break Thanksgiving bread with my mom’s side of the family. Any way you put it, as siblings within the greater context of the holiday season, couldn’t have had it any better.

Dinner would come at around 4 PM, as darkness was beginning to fall, the late afternoon light being blocked by Ebenezer mountain , which stood as a sentinel, protecting us from the busy world from which we came for the weekend.

The spread of food which had been presented before us took my grandmother much of the preceding day and all of Thanksgiving morning and afternoon to prepare. But before passing plates, there were several moments of utter quiet as we each reflected on our good fortune to be associated with such an incredible family. In the earliest years, my grandmother would read the above prayer and as we grew, each of us children would read these same words. It was a rare moment of contemplation, solemnity, and joy all wrapped in a warm blanket of love and gratitude. Only then were we as kids allowed to partake in the feast set before us.

Backing Down: Not on my Worst Day!

Going at it  Credit: Free Pic

Recently, I was forced to relearn an important lesson, a lesson that originated from within my DNA and reinforced many times over from  numerous life experiences. I am sixty-four.

It began innocently enough while my wife was out walking our three dogs on a trail we’ve made that follows our fenceline on all four sides. She came in and told me of a fellow who was mowing the property just across the road. I had just had abdominal surgery to rid me of an undiagnosed infectious mass of fluid that had been growing behind my liver and had hospitalized me several times over the past two and a half years. I was just getting to the point where I could walk around with a cane but I hadn’t been able to walk outside for over a month and was unstable and still in a lot of pain.

Some Context Leading Up to That Day

The surgery I am referring to was the last stop on the train to resolve a serious illness that I had been battling for over two years. To say the least, it was an invasive surgery and involved shifting my organs to look for more infectious material, some of which had to be cut away. I lost a liter of blood and required a transfusion, both things unforeseen in anything the surgeon might run into while being able to finally view the extent of the problem. I did not know how it would have been possible for me to acquire such an obscure illness unless it was connected to an emergency gall bladder surgery that I had gotten several years before.

The gall bladder surgery was performed at one o’clock in the morning, sometime back in 2019, and not by a surgeon qualified to perform that type of surgery. After weeks of trying to get me to go, I was literally on death’s doorstep by the time my wife was able to get me in the truck and en route to the closest emergency room. It was only then that I learned of how bad off I truly was. My gall bladder had turned necrotic and the surrounding area was gangrenous. This led to an advanced case of sepsis. I didn’t know who or where I was and couldn’t name the president of the United States. After that woefully messy surgery I was hospitalized for nine days until my blood was cleared for release. As bad as the surgery and overall experience had been, I was thankful. There was no doubt that they had saved my life. It was my fault that the problem was allowed to progress to such a state.

Not long after returning home from the gall bladder surgery, there had been some signs that my innards were still in distress and my wife called the hospital surgeon’s office on a number of occasions to inquire about the pain and bloating I was experiencing again and was told that those were normal symptoms after a surgery like mine. After six months had passed, the pain had lessened but the bloating gradually continued until it looked like I was pregnant in the week leading up to an emergency, twenty-one day hospitalization in January of 2023. That stay included pumping four liters of nefarious, infected puss from my abdomen and then an “all hands on deck” rush to diagnose the root cause. By the time I went home, my blood had been studied ad nauseum, a cornucopia of cultures had been grown, I’d undergone every type of imaging there is, and still, I remained without a diagnosis. In other words, it was still with me and would be returning.

I was assigned to a lauded infectious disease doctor and went on a two year odyssey to diagnose the problem and, with some luck, save what was left of my life. Sooner or later , this infection was going to kill me, the bacteria were that pernicious. Without knowing where the fluid was coming from, there was no way to stop it from leaking into my abdomen inviting another round of infection and accelerated fluid buildup requiring three more trips to to hospital to chase down the infection and drain the fluid. At one point, I was married to an external fluid drain (an ugly bag and a catheter) for four months. There were three other drain installations but for just one to three months. During this time but unrelated (I think), I was diagnosed with high-grade bladder cancer. For the cancer, it’s been sixteen months and three surgeries and I’ll be in treatment for what looks like some time to come. It looked good for seven months, but I’d been told of its return just days before the incident.

It is all of this that I was carrying on my shoulders that day.

The Incident

Effectively, I had been unable to attend to our country home and property for about four years. For a perfectionist who’s always taken pride in taking care of my things, I’d begun to lose my mind. Because we have three wonderful dogs and an inordinate number of rattlesnakes on our Central Texas property, my biggest priority is in keeping the grass cut. If I don’t get to it in a few weeks, the brush begins to take hold and the native grasses will grow to three feet. It had been over a month since I’d been able to mow it with the field mower. I was about to bust with anxiety over not getting to it. But I’m the type of person who’s grown highly accustomed to doing virtually anything and everything myself. If you live in a subdivision, mowing isn’t that much of a chore, but on four acres of Texas brush country, it can be. You need the appropriate (expensive) equipment and there are lots of potential hazards to pay attention to.

I asked Genie to run over and see if the guy had time to swing by to discuss our place when he was done with his current job. I had a pit in my stomach and I hadn’t even spoken with him. It was in the heat of the day and there’s no way I could hobble around and show him everything. The main thing was whether he had a mowing setup that could handle tall grass and undulating, somewhat rough terrain. Though it looks pretty when mowed, it’s not a golf course. His equipment checked out and, since I knew he didn’t have insurance for his one-man business, I asked him “If you’re out there and you somehow have a failure with your equipment, does that come out of your pocket, or mine?”. He said what I was hoping he’d say, “Mine…I would never…”. Since I couldn’t show him the property and the potentially now hidden obstacles, I showed him pics of the various sections of the property so he could see what it looked like just after a mowing. This is where he grumbled something like “I don’t need to see no stinkin’ pictures”. I quizzed him on it and, in an aggravated voice said “I’ve been mowing for ten years” and yada yada. I told him that “that had nothing to do with it and that he’d realize the relevancy after he mowed over one of three old, six inch stumps obscured by the now tall grass…stumps that I had pointed out clearly”. He grumbled some more as he walked towards his truck. I almost put it to an end there. He sat on the tailgate of his truck wasting time. I said, ‘do you want the job or not?” He said yes but that he’d first have to run the few miles down the road to get gas. It was 99 degrees and I could see the signs of heat exhaustion creeping up on him. I suggested that, since he’d just done that job across the way that I’m sure he was feeling the heat and probably pretty tired and that he show-up in the morning, fueled up and ready to go. I asked him again for a price, either a not-to exceed or an hourly rate so I could figure out how much I was willing to spend. He got in his truck to get gas and said he’d give me a price when he got back and drove away.

With the surgery and ridiculously painful recovery, I hadn’t been out in the mid-day heat (approaching 100 deg that day) and I could feel my strength waning, but I think I was the better off between us. I went into the house to wait and it was right at an hour when he got back from gassing-up just three miles down the road. I didn’t mention it, only asked for a price. He still didn’t have one so, without wanting to over-expose myself with this guy, I offered to pay him $120 for three hours and we’d take a look and adjust things if necessary. I showed him my rig and said that it takes me between three and four hours to do the whole property. His machine had a heavy duty deck and actually had the same engine as mine.

After two and a half hours he came back and loaded his machine before we did our agreed upon walk around. He said he was done and had been out there for five hours. This wasn’t the first bald-faced lie I’d heard that day. No one had ever been brazen enough to look me in the eye and expect me to acquiesce to such a lie. That was it. My patience, which had already been tested to its absolute limit that day, left my body and I felt something very powerful take its place: immediate and unadulterated adrenaline-assisted anger. He’d already been speaking to me in a much louder, more aggressive tone for the past twenty minutes. I kept my tone cool and unflustered, with each word being spoken firmly and measured in terms of not elevating the sound of my voice to match his. I kept my wits and readied myself for what was coming. “That’s the third of three seriously bad lies you’ve told me today and all I want from you now is to pack up your shit and get the fuck off of my property…NOW!” He approached me so that his face was no further than six inches from my face. He started to scream something and no sooner than his spittle hit my face, I shoved him so hard that he barely stood, backpedaling at speed to keep from falling until he slammed into the open driver’s side door and crumpled to the ground. The distance from where I shoved him to where he now lay was between twelve and fifteen feet. I don’t know where that power came from. It was a power I had known during my more youthful years but power that shouldn’t have been there before the stitches from my surgery had been pulled and I was still half out of it from the immense abdominal pain which remained. At first, I thought I might have opened the surgical wound or tore an abdominal muscle, but there was no time for that now. I heard “I’d come right back at you if you didn’t need that cane and hadn’t just gotten out of the hospital!”. I replied “don’t let that stop you!” He threatened me by saying “I should go home, grab my gun. and come back and put some holes in you!” I laughed  and said “try me! Or, how ‘bout the one that I’m sure is in the glove compartment of your truck, eight feet away.” This is one of the poorest counties in Central Texas, and both open and concealed carry are legal here. You can bet that people of all persuasions either have a gun on their person or, if they don’t plan on being far from their truck, there’ll be one under the seat or in the glove box. He didn’t respond but just sat there, propped up by his truck door huffing and puffing until I walked over to him “Now, unless you want to continue, I told you to get the fuck off of my property!”, but, I added “I don’t ever want to see you out here again, you dumb son-of-a bitch!” After getting into his truck, I gave him $140 because it was hot, and he was very hot, and I was still happy to have the mowing checked off my list for a week, or two. Plus, temporary emotions aside, it was the right thing to do. If he had finished it, I had planned on giving him $200, which is the amount he said he would have changed as he peeled out of our driveway, flipping me off and screaming obscenities as he went. This was a sixty-eight year old man acting no differently than a four year old. Somewhere during the scuffle, he yelled “twenty years ago, me and some brutha’s used to kick serious ass on white boys like you!” I had not wanted to bring race into the conversation, so I let it go unchallenged. But I couldn’t help myself from laughing in his direction.

After all was said and done, I went inside only to have my wife castigate me for “losing my cool”. I told her that I wouldn’t consider myself a man if I hadn’t. My insides were churning over what had just happened. She hadn’t been able to hear my voice but had heard his as she watched from the front door. I said “that ought to tell you something.” When he got so far into my personal space, yelling at the top of his lungs, that by itself was enough for me to legally defend myself. He obviously didn’t realize it, but getting that close to me had put me at an advantage and being up against my chest gave me numerous options and some strong leverage. The danger had grown to be imminent and there was no more time for thinking, only acting by giving him the hardest shove I could muster in the condition I was in.

As a younger man, even into my fifties, I’d had more confrontations than I can count. A few were pretty serious, but, because of my back problems and health issues like I just described, my body has paid a steep price and I had lost more than half of my strength and mobility. For an athletic, forever on the move, and well conditioned guy, this has been very difficult to handle.  There is no way to describe what your body and mind go through in the seconds before an imminently dangerous encounter with another human being. Every fiber of muscle is receiving all the adrenaline your adrenal glands can pump out. Primal chemicals are released from your brain and mind and body come together in a vastly heightened state, so much so that it would be impossible to not react with all the resources you can render. For me in my condition, I had no choice but to hold my ground, dispense with the cane and repel this person, hopefully hard enough to put an end to things and “defuse” the situation. It had been a long time since I’d experienced that kind of adrenaline rush and it felt damned good to feel so alive and in control! I actually told him as much and thanked him for his contribution.

After things settled and the house quieted, I told my wife that I was proud of the way I handled myself and wouldn’t change a thing except for listening to my gut during those hours earlier and asking him to leave before he even got started on the job. This was the lesson I was reminded of that day and will be my only regret from the day of the incident. After collecting herself and hearing me out, my wife apologized, said that she was proud of me, and thanked me for protecting our home and family, particularly in the condition I was in. Our family is comprised of she and I and our three wonderful dogs, whom I’m sure would have been only  too pleased to have gotten a piece of this guy. All I had to do was call out to my wife to let them out. They would have heard the entire thing and been chomping at the bit the entire time. It never occurred to me because I’m sure I was wanting to keep them out of harm’s way. If there were a time for him to go for a gun, which I am certain was just a reach across his seat away, that would have been it.

What is that old expression, “all’s well that ends well”. That’s what it had boiled down to. Of course, it crossed my mind that he could very well show up at any time only this time it would have been with sons. buddies, or both, But, in the course of our not-so-friendly dialogue, I had left him with something to think about, and that was that nothing would make me happier than for him to come busting through my front door on the darkest of nights. He knew damned well that I’d be lying in wait with my own arsenal and dogs at the ready. I never mentioned having guns of my own. That wasn’t necessary. Everyone in these parts is well-armed. On top of that. I grew up around guns, hunting, and shooting. We were taught to never let-on about the family guns, even to good friends. There was no reason to and it only provides fodder for that information to fall into the wrong hands and gives those of the criminal sort a reason to break in and steal what you’ve got, and what they want. In the 70’s, long before people would do anything to get their hands on prescription drugs, gun theft was the root cause of many a break-in.

It’s over now and with any luck, I will never again have to deal with such an event. We live a quiet, extremely rural life and I intend to keep it that way.

How do you start improvising on guitar? I can play the scales and chords but I don’t know how to make it sound like music.

Originally Written for Quora

Context

I started playing and collecting guitars as a middle-aged adult fifteen years ago and have written all sorts of things about my love of the instrument, including posts on vintage acoustic guitars, collecting guitars, my favorite guitars and guitarists, “boutique guitars”, guitar comparisons, reviews, the state of the industry, guitar maintenance, improving technique, but not so much on learning guitar from scratch. There is already an overwhelming amount of information available online and via YouTube, which is already a big enough problem with learning guitar today.

This was a very specific question that both irked me in its unwitting audacity and had me feeling compelled to provide a solid answer for the “greater good”. Almost every player wrestles with”improvisation” (learning to be a good “lead” guitarist) and tries, with mixed results (usually ending in quiet, long-term frustration), to accelerate the process by cutting every corner they can think of.

——–

You mention chords and scales as if there are a few, when there are hundreds. No offense, but it’s become pretty mainstream to want to shave learning guitar down to a few simple stages. Because it’s become a part of popular culture doesn’t make it any easier than it was twenty years ago. In fact, with more and more people wanting to play, there’s so much conflicting and complete misinformation now that it may be more difficult than at any time before. Too many choices. Try to focus on what I’m telling you here.

Here’s the deal: If you’re that far along with chords and scales, then you invariably know your keys. This is the “playing by ear” part for each of us, or, at least where it really comes into play (NPI)…if not far sooner.

In the beginning, choose a popular (used in countless tunes, as, say “E” for blues) key in your preferred genre and load some slow to medium tempo backing tracks in the chosen key. You may be able to hear the chord transitions right away (or you can use an app that shows you…or, just lookup the song). Listen carefully and play along with the chords only to get the tempo and your rhythm down.

Next, use the applicable scale or scales that you wish to try, and choose a starting place on the finger board and, while listening carefully for the chord transitions, begin to experiment (improvise) with single note phrasings over the chords.

If you do this enough, your ears should take you where you want to go.

Then begin experimenting with some of your favorite songs, playing along and attempting to nail the leads note for note or see if you can compliment those leads as you might picture a “call and respond” session between two guitar greats sharing the stage. The tempo will dictate whether this is workable or there just isn’t enough space. You’ll note that they only do this fun exercise on certain songs. Then go back to challenging yourself and play your favorite genre on your preferred platform. I use Spotify the most. Play a station or selection of tracks on that search and see how you do without skipping through songs (which is fine at first) as you progress.

You’ll quickly find what your stregths and weaknesses are and what guitar styles you wish to emulate, while always bearing in mind that the ultimate goal is to find and refine your own style.

Take ample, separate, practice time to work on your technical abilities like bends, vibrato, pull offs, hammer ons, and all the tools necessary to turn yourself into a complete player.

You owe me $200! Ha! 😆

How Do You Feel About Hunting and Hunters?

First Written in Quora

In Colorado, during the 80’s, 90’s, and 2000’s, though I was engaged in all sorts of mountain sports, the season I looked forward to the most was hunting season. I was able to get an early start on my hunting life having grown up in Adirondack Mountains of Northern New York state, where you can begin your hunting journey at fourteen, as long as it is supervised by an adult. You are free to go about your business alone at sixteen and you could hunt both archery and rifle during separate seasons during the same year. When combined, as an “Adirondacker”, I could hunt for what amounted to two months each fall. During my time there, the seasons were each about a month long. This is the way it was (at least during the seven years (from age 14 to 21) that I hunted there, and for many years thereafter.  The state managed Adirondack Park’s 2.6 million acres are comprised of both state and private lands under a policy designed to make a “Forever Wild” zone well distant from the much higher populations located farther south, and, of course, the population centers of New York City and Long Island, and, to a lesser extent, the Albany area and it’s two “Sister Cities”. The state’s Department of Environmental Conservation (ENCON) and the Adirondack Park Agency APA) managed hunter populations in the Adirondacks and ENCON alone managed the rest of the state’s hunting units, which varied greatly in hunter numbers throughout the state’s very different hunting regions. I learned by following my father’s size thirteen footsteps up and down some of the most rugged country in the northeast. For my dad and me, archery practice began in June or July, preparing for the season which opened in September. Rifle practice took place throughout the year and was not limited to a few days or weeks leading up to the season, which began right after archery season had concluded. Rifle shooting was just another part of life and we were always prepared for that year’s window of hunting opportunities.

After college, I followed my dream and landed in Colorado, where I would spend a good part of the next thirty years. Colorado is an “either-or” state, meaning you have to choose between archery and rifle seasons and cannot hunt both modes in the same year. If I had to choose overall, it’d have been archery because it’s nearly a month long versus the five to nine day allocations depending on which of the four relatively short rifle seasons a given hunter elects to hunt. Even nine days wasn’t enough time to satisfy my annual needs. So I began a schedule of two years of archery followed by a year of rifle. As I neared the halfway point of my hunting career, I made the switch to archery only and these seasons would go on to contain some of my best hunting memories.

But things changed significantly over the course of those three decades and by the time I reached my late forties, I was coming full circle with my thoughts and feelings about the sport. I can’t speak as knowledgeably about the other Western states other than to say that some are managing their big game animals, namely, deer and elk, better than others. There are simply too many tags being sold in Colorado and far too many hunters in a given game unit at a given time. Because of this, the gene pool for elk on National Forest lands has gotten weaker every year and continues to worsen. You can see it in the size and antler growth of many four and five year old bulls and the mature bulls are getting fewer and farther between in some of the most popular units. With such a huge shift over three decades, Colorado has become the Pennsylvania of the West. Too many small, ratty looking deer with ticks all over them. Ticks in these kinds of numbers are a bio-indicator, a foreboding sign of a tragically weakened ecosystem. I lived in PA for two years and never had any interest in the kind of slaughter that takes place there every autumn. Since the state is so populated with infrastructure such as roads and four lane highways every few miles, a good fraction of the deer get pushed out of the woods only to become roadkill.

For Colorado to recover, it is imperative that a rotation, not unlike those used on crop lands, be enacted for game units to be “rested” for a period of several years, with the units having the poorest health getting preferential treatment. Some adjustments need to be made to the availability of deer to be hunted, increasing the numbers of licences sold in many units with burgeoning deer populations. It’s become a complicated problem, perhaps one with which the newly released wolves can help once they’ve become established. But, because Colorado is the most populated state to have launched a wolf recovery program, we need to treat them with kid gloves and keep our heads about us if the program is to be a success. Only time will tell, but, based on many years of personal and intimate relationships with various parts of the state, I don’t see wolf reintroduction in Colorado as being viable, given how little space there is between populated areas.

At 64, with a weakened body due to several life altering illnesses, I haven’t been able to hunt in the manner I enjoy for several years and will reluctantly say that my hunting days are over. With things being as they are today, I wouldn’t want to hunt anyway. Perhaps armed only with a good camera and certainly not during hunting season. One thing is for sure, Colorado’s elk are in need of some radical policy changes, even if it comes in the form of a more limited income stream for the state. Though revenues from large numbers of hunters have at least been partially responsible for keeping Colorado’s smaller towns on the map, the deer and elk need to come first for a while.

Encountering a bull elk such as the one pictured while hunting on public lands (BLM, National Forest), in Colorado, has become an extremely rare event due to far too many hunters (as allowed by the vast number of hunting licences sold by the state’s Department of Fish and Wildlife) which has resulted in chronic herd mismanagement and the highly inordinate numbers of elk taken during Colorado’s hunting seasons. Put simply, it has been the short-term value state wildlife officials have placed on the huge sums of money put into state coffers at the longer-term expense of the well-being of the state’s elk (and deer) populations.